Filter

Cuisines
Select cuisines
Features
Select features

The Best 15 Restaurants in Fire Island, New York (NY), United States

Rachel`s Bakery and Restaurant
Rachel`s Bakery and Restaurant
4.5
24 reviews
American Restaurant American Cafe

325 Bay Walk, Ocean Beach, Fire Island, NY 11770-2030, Fire Island

Best bakery on Fire Island. Their cookies are terrific. Restaurant food is very good, a nice change from other OB establ